Coffee Custard Recipe – Silky Italian Espresso Dessert with Whipped Cream

Coffee Custard Recipe

This Coffee Custard recipe (Caffè in Forchetta) combines the rich, robust flavors of freshly brewed espresso with a silky, creamy custard base for an indulgent Italian dessert. Michael Bonacini demonstrates how a few simple ingredients—milk, cream, eggs, sugar, and coffee—can be transformed into a decadent dessert that’s both elegant and approachable. Perfect for after-dinner indulgence, brunch, or for keeping on hand for spontaneous coffee cravings, this dessert is as versatile as it is flavorful. Served with a topping of thick whipped cream and a dusting of cocoa powder, each bite delivers a smooth, creamy texture paired with deep espresso aroma.

The Inspiration

Caffè in Forchetta is a traditional Italian dessert that highlights the country’s love for coffee-infused sweets. Inspired by classic custards and Italian cafés, this dessert is designed to balance the bitter richness of espresso with a subtle sweetness and creamy texture. Michael Bonacini’s take emphasizes accessibility and elegance, making it possible to create a café-quality dessert at home. The mason jars used for baking are a nod to modern presentation while keeping the custards perfectly portioned and convenient for storage. This dessert embodies the Italian approach of combining simple, high-quality ingredients to achieve complex, memorable flavors.

Coffee custard is versatile and celebratory, ideal for entertaining guests or preparing in advance for a dinner party. The slow-baked custard sets with a delicate crust around the edges while remaining silky in the center, creating a dessert that’s visually appealing and deeply satisfying. The topping of thick whipped cream and cocoa powder adds layers of texture and taste, making each jar a luxurious treat.

Ingredients

• 1 cup (240 ml) milk
• 1 cup (240 ml) whipping cream
• 1 cup (240 ml) freshly brewed espresso (or substitute with freshly brewed coffee)
• 4 egg yolks
• 2 eggs
• ¾ cup (180 ml) sugar
• Thick whipped cream, for topping
• Cocoa powder, for dusting

Special Equipment:

• Small mason jars

Method

• Preheat oven to 300 F (150 C).
• Heat milk and cream in a saucepan until it just starts to steam.
• Remove mixture from heat and whisk in freshly brewed espresso.
• Whisk together egg yolks, eggs, and sugar.
• Pour half of the cream mixture into the yolk and sugar, whisking briskly to combine.
• Now pour the yolk and cream mixture back into the pot with the remaining cream mixture, whisking continuously until combined.
• Carefully pour custard mixture into 8 small mason jars.
• Place mason jars in a large casserole dish and fill the dish with about 1-inch (2.5 cm) of boiling water. Cover with aluminum foil.
• Transfer casserole dish to oven and bake for 90 minutes or until puddings have set with a slight crust around the edges.
• Remove the casserole dish from the oven, carefully remove the mason jars, and let cool.
• Transfer mason jars to refrigerator to chill completely.
• To serve, top the chilled custards with tufts of thick whipped cream and dust with cocoa powder.
• Buon appetito!

Serving Suggestions

Coffee Custard is an elegant dessert that can be served on a variety of occasions—from casual family dinners to formal dinner parties. These custards pair beautifully with biscotti or almond cookies for added crunch, or alongside a small glass of dessert wine such as Vin Santo or Marsala to enhance the rich coffee flavors. For brunch, the custards can be enjoyed with a cup of espresso or cappuccino, providing a double boost of Italian coffee experience.

The dessert can be prepared in advance, making it perfect for entertaining. Simply bake, chill, and top with whipped cream and cocoa powder just before serving. For a luxurious touch, garnish with shaved chocolate or a few coffee beans. Coffee Custard is also versatile in presentation—serve in elegant ramekins or mini glasses if mason jars aren’t available, and you can sprinkle cinnamon or nutmeg for a warm spice accent. Its smooth, creamy texture contrasted with lightly whipped cream ensures that each bite is indulgent yet refined.

Final Thoughts

This Coffee Custard (Caffè in Forchetta) recipe is a celebration of Italian dessert craftsmanship, combining rich espresso flavor with creamy, silky custard. Michael Bonacini’s recipe brings the elegance of Italian cafés into your home kitchen while remaining simple and accessible. The careful tempering of eggs, slow baking, and chilling process ensures a smooth custard with a delicate crust, while the whipped cream and cocoa topping add a finishing touch that is both visually and texturally appealing.